On Tue Oct 24 01:56:40 2017, each@isc.org wrote: > > Are we in agreement that HMAC-MD5 is the best choice for default? > > I'm guessing you meant "is not"? > > I definitely want the default to change, but since we've already shipped > beta, it shouldn't change for 9.12. I've pushed code to the branch that > prints a warning message and promises to change the default in the future. => as I pushed alternative to HMAC-MD5 a long time ago you already know my opinion. BTW most arguments against MD5 are applicable so will be applied to SHA-1 (or with other words in "no reason at all" IMHO there is a missing "technical").